Choosing between solar shingles and panels can be confusing. Yes, it is true that shingles offer a good look to your house, but solar panels offer simple installation. However, both are good options for harvesting solar energy. However, here is a comparison of solar panels vs solar shingles to help you choose better.

Solar Panels Vs Solar Shingles

Solar Panels: They are made from PV cells that convert solar energy into electricity. They offer different efficiency based on their type: mono, poly, or amorphous cells. Solar panels are installed on roofs and are also mounted to maximize sunlight exposure.

Solar Shingles: They belong to building-integrated photovoltaics (BIPV) and contain solar cells within the roofing material. Based on their design, they effectively conceal the solar cells.

Nonetheless, understanding the differences between solar roof shingles vs. solar roof panels is important. This can help you make a more sound decision.

FeaturesSolar panelsSolar shingles
InstallationMounted on rooftops or slopesIntegrated with roofing tiles
Efficiency (energy production)HighLess than PV panels
DurabilityHighly durable and robustLess durable
Cleaning and MaintenanceEasy to maintain and cleanDifficult and challenging
Battery integrationEasy to addComplex process
Availability (in market)Easy and widespread availabilityLimited availability
Visibility (aesthetics)Visible on rooftopsIntegrated seamlessly

Solar Shingles Pros and Cons

ProsCons
More visually appealing than traditional solar panelsTypically, less efficient than solar panels
Often permitted by homeowners associations (HOAs) that restrict solar panelsMore expensive than solar panels, especially for roofs not needing replacement
Can reduce overall cost if roof replacement is neededDifficult to expand production capacity compared to panels
Eliminates the need to remove panels for roof replacementShingles are much more dependent on the slope of your roof
Matches the lifespan of traditional roofing materialsTakes longer to install and finding experienced contractors can be challenging

Don’t forget to go through this solar shingles roofing guide for in-depth understanding.

Solar Panels Pros and Cons

ProsCons
More affordableHighly efficient panels are more expensive, e.g. monocrystalline solar panels
Widely available and with many installersLow visually appeal and looks bulky
More efficient at converting sunlight to energyRequires roof to be in good condition
Easier to expand solar capacity by adding more panelsSeparate warranties for roof and panels
Panels can be adjusted for optimal positioning and increased productivityInstalling solar panels may void your roof warranty

Find out solar panel output: winter vs summer.

Lifetime and Durability of Solar Roof Shingles and Solar Panels

Solar Panels Vs Solar Shingles Major Differences & Comparisons

Both solar panels and solar shingles are designed for a long lifespan, typically lasting 25 to 30 years. The solar cell structure itself is built for durability, ensuring continued energy production over this extended period. Here’s a breakdown of their longevity:

  • Solar Roof Shingles: Compared to traditional asphalt shingles. They share a similar lifespan to solar panels (25-30 years) and are typically covered by a 20-year product warranty against manufacturing defects.
  • Solar Panels: With a design life of 25-30 years, most solar panels come backed by a 25-year product warranty that covers manufacturing defects. This means the manufacturer will repair or replace faulty panels during this timeframe.

Cost of Solar Panels vs Solar Shingles

Solar panels cost around $2.85 per watt whereas shingles cost between $4 and $7 per watt. When it comes to cost, solar panels are the clear winner. However, if you need a new roof anyway, solar shingles can be a smart long-term investment.

  • Solar Panels: More affordable due to established technology and widespread installation. Expect costs around $2.85 per watt, with a typical system costing $15,000-$20,000.
  • Solar Shingles: A premium option due to their newer technology and dual functionality (roofing + solar). Costs range from $4-$7 per watt, with an average installation between $25,000-$60,000.

Cross-Reference: Solar Panel vs. Solar Shingles Cost

Costs of Maintenance of Solar Roof Shingles vs. Solar Panels

While both solar panels and shingles require minimal upkeep, there are some key differences in potential repair costs.

  • Solar Shingles – Higher Repair Costs: Since solar shingles function as both roof and solar energy sources, damage to the shingles could necessitate repairs to both the roofing and solar components, potentially leading to higher costs.
  • Solar Panels – Simpler, Lower Repair Costs: Traditional panels are separate from the roof itself. Issues with panels are typically easier and potentially less expensive to fix as they don’t involve the complexities of repairing a roof.

Don’t neglect these 8 benefits of cleaning solar panels.

In the end, the choice between solar panels vs solar shingles depends on your priorities. Solar panels are generally more affordable upfront and easier to relocate, making them ideal for budget-conscious homeowners or those who might move soon. Solar shingles, however, offer a sleek look and integrate seamlessly with a roof replacement, perfect for those prioritizing aesthetics and long-term investment in their home.

Share.
mm

Olivia is committed to green energy and works to help ensure our planet's long-term habitability. She takes part in environmental conservation by recycling and avoiding single-use plastic.

Leave A Reply