Everyone is putting more and more emphasis on actions that promote environmental conservation and sustainability as awareness of the environment and sustainable development grows. There are several choices for renewable energy. We shall analyze is solar energy better than geothermal energy in this article. Below, we contrast Solar energy VS Geothermal energy to better understand how successful the two sources are.
Solar Energy VS Geothermal Energy: Which is Right for You?
Most people who are asked what green energy options they are aware of or considering incorporating into their own homes would name solar panels right away. Yet, there are other sources of green energy besides solar. Moreover, geothermal systems have a smaller environmental impact and save energy. Which one is best for you: solar energy vs geothermal energy, then?
In contrast to geothermal energy, which originates from the earth, solar energy is derived from the sun. Because they employ already-existing heat sources to warm (or cool) our homes, both are regarded as green energy. Installing solar panels on your roof in order to collect solar energy is what we mean when we talk about using solar energy from residences. Digging beneath your home to get earth’s heat is what we mean when we talk about employing geothermal energy.
Both methods have many benefits, as well as some disadvantages. Being independent of changing gas costs is a major benefit of either method, though.
Is Solar Energy Better than Geothermal Energy?
Renewable energy is a fantastic method to power your house or business, reduce your energy costs, and benefit the environment. It can be difficult to select Solar energy VS Geothermal energy as the best one for you. To know is solar energy better than geothermal energy you should consider your objectives as well as the available area. There are a few distinct choices you’ll need to make while deciding between geothermal and solar energy to determine which is better.
1. Weather is Important
What kind of weather you have is the first important factor to consider when deciding between solar energy and geothermal energy. Both types of green energy come from naturally occurring sources, however, solar energy needs the sun to generate electricity. The amount of energy you can produce with a solar energy system may be limited if you reside in an area with little sunlight. But with more recent technologies, solar may work well even in cloudier environments.
If you want to be more environmentally friendly and reduce your energy costs, geothermal energy is also an option in these situations.
Also Read: What Questions to Ask Before Getting Solar Panels?
2. Start-Up Prices
Geothermal is more expensive than solar. The cost of setup is a significant factor to consider while deciding between two energies. Geothermal system installation is extremely expensive. It involves digging, often a lot of digging and installing all the necessary equipment, which is costly and time-consuming. Solar power is far more affordable and simpler to deploy. Solar is a superior choice in this situation if the initial cost of your energy source is crucial.
3. The Kind of Space You Have
Each of these energy sources requires a large amount of room. Solar panel installation requires space, either on the ground or on your roof. As you may not have much roof space for solar panels if your home is small, the advantage might not be as great. A few solar panels here and there can provide some tiny advantages, but if you want to make a significant improvement, you will need to cover your entire roof or a significant piece of your land with solar panels.
Yet, to produce electricity from geothermal sources, loops of pipes must be buried, sometimes several feet deep. More pipes and excavating would be required the more energy you wanted to produce. This implies a significant amount of labor and land use to establish a sustainable energy source.
4. Long-Term Gains
The final factor to take into account is what the advantages would be over a lengthy period of time once you are aware of how much each solution costs and how much room you require.
For areas with poor weather or little above-ground space, geothermal energy is a fantastic alternative, but it has different advantages from solar. Although the energy you generate with geothermal cannot completely offset the electricity you consume, it can eventually result in lower long-term heating and cooling costs.
On the other side, solar energy can increase or even completely replace your need for electricity, which will significantly reduce your power cost. It’s also crucial to keep in mind that solar energy produces electricity to power your entire home, farm, or establishment, whereas geothermal energy simply pertains to your heating and cooling system. After this, let’s learn what is the difference between geothermal and solar energy.
Also See: 4 Advantages Of Solar Water Heater
What is the Difference Between Geothermal and Solar Energy?
The difference between geothermal and solar energy is as discussed below:
Geothermal Energy
1. You need a backup heat source because geo can only be used when the temperature is 28 degrees or higher. Frequently, all you need as a backup is your current furnace or boiler.
2. Because they heat and cool your home, geothermal systems can nearly entirely decrease your reliance on the grid.
3. A heat pump is a decent substitute for a complete geothermal system if you want to save money and lessen your environmental impact but don’t want to dig up your yard.
4. Unless you already use propane, choosing geothermal is actually more about lowering your carbon footprint than it is about saving money right now because gas prices are so low. When homeowners transition to geothermal energy from propane, they save a significant amount of money.
5. Geothermal systems often require less maintenance because they are shielded underground, even though their initial installation is more labor-intensive than solar panels.
Also Read: Solar Inverter Vs Normal Inverter- What are the Differences?
Solar Energy
1. Systems that use solar energy come in two varieties.
- Solar heating may heat your home and your water.
- Photovoltaics generates electricity.
2. As installing geothermal systems necessitates breaking ground, installing solar panels is simpler than installing geothermal systems.
3. The electric solar subsidies are excellent (better than the rebates for geothermal). Both require about the same amount of upfront investment.
4. Solar panels lose a substantial amount of efficiency when they become dirty.
5. The fact that it frequently rains when the temperatures are really low is one of the reasons solar heating is not a good option for heating back up over Geothermal. With this, you have understood what the difference between geothermal and solar energy is.
Also See: Solar Module Vs Solar Panel: What’s the Difference?
Does Geothermal Produce More Energy than Solar?
Most homes use solar PVs as they are sustainable investments. Most manufacturers boast that these systems only have around a 20% decline in their performance after 25 years of use. On the other hand, a geothermal system is multi-functional, it cools, heats, regulates humidity, and also provides hot water. It has industry-topping efficiency ratings. With a good underground pipe system (or loop) to pull enough energy from the earth, the geothermal unit efficiencies can also go over 500%.
With geothermal energy, you can lower your heating and cooling bills over the long term, but it cannot replace the electricity you use. On the other hand, solar energy can add to or eliminate your electricity usage.
In the end, it’s not about who produces more energy, it’s all about how they are sized, installed, and used. With this, you should have understood does geothermal produce more energy than solar. After this, let’s learn about geothermal energy vs solar energy cost.
Geothermal Energy vs Solar Energy Cost: Which is a More Suitable Option?
Geothermal energy vs solar energy cost is an intriguing one to consider before opting for any of these options.
At around $50/MWh, geothermal energy is the most affordable source of power available where it is viable. Onshore wind, gas, and hydro are all competitive with one another at about $70/MWh, but the cost of gas and hydro is generally stable while the cost of wind is falling quickly.
Geothermal energy has the drawback of only being useful in locations where lava from the Earth’s mantle touches the surface, as it does in volcanoes and a few other hotspots, most frequently around tectonic plate borders. For the totally volcanic islands of Hawaii and Iceland as well as some of California, which has a plate boundary running through it, it is a fantastic source of energy.
The average installed price for geothermal energy between 2010 and 2021 varied between 2,700 and 5,600 dollars per kilowatt, with a peak of 5,509 dollars per kilowatt in 2012. The average installation price for geothermal systems in 2023 is $3,991 USD per kilowatt.
Solar and wind energy are more expensive but can be installed across much bigger regions. Depending on the style and model, solar panels currently cost around $3,500 to $35,000, or around $16,000 on average. Despite the fact that solar panels can help you save money on energy prices, it’s crucial to understand the whole setup costs of solar panels so you can create a budget.
Most people, however, are unable to install both technologies at once. It would be more practical to install either geothermal or solar, as installing both would be a significant job with lots of logistics and a significant combined installation cost. Both of these renewable additions are ultimately a good choice, provided they are properly scaled and installed.
Recommended: 5 Best Generator for Off Grid Battery Charging